Group Boycotting
Group boycotting is two or more competitors agreeing not to do business with someone, such as brokers agreeing not to show a discount firm's listings. Any broker may refuse a deal on its own; the agreement is what can violate Section 1 of the Sherman Act and Florida's Antitrust Act.
Group boycotting is an agreement among competitors to refuse to deal with a person or business, or to pressure others not to, in order to exclude or discipline a competitor. In real estate it usually means brokers or agents agreeing to avoid a competing firm, its listings, or a vendor. It can violate Section 1 of the Sherman Act (15 U.S.C. §1) and the Florida Antitrust Act of 1980 (Chapter 542, Florida Statutes).
Brokers compete, and each one is free to decide whom to work with. A broker can decline a co-broke, refuse a client or stop using a vendor for any legitimate business reason, as long as the decision is its own. The legal line is crossed when competitors make that decision together. An agreement does not need to be written or formal; a nod around a lunch table can be enough evidence. This page explains what counts as a boycott, what the federal and Florida laws say, a worked example of the exposure, and the habits that keep a brokerage out of trouble. It is general information, not legal advice.
What Counts as a Group Boycott in Real Estate
- Brokers agreeing not to show, or to steer buyers away from, a competitor's listings, for example a flat-fee or discount brokerage.
- Agreeing not to co-broke with a firm because of how it prices its services.
- Firms agreeing to stop using a lender, title company, inspector or other vendor to punish it for working with a competitor.
- An association or listing service adopting a rule whose purpose or effect is to shut out a type of competitor.
- Agreeing with competitors on which clients or territories each firm will avoid. That is market allocation, a related violation.
Group boycotts often travel with price fixing: an agreement to shut out a firm because it charges less is an agreement about price.
What the Law Says
- Sherman Act, Section 1 (15 U.S.C. §1): every contract, combination or conspiracy in restraint of trade is illegal. Courts treat some group boycotts among competitors as illegal per se, meaning no business justification is considered; others are judged under the rule of reason. The FTC's guidance on group boycotts explains the distinction.
- Criminal exposure: a Sherman Act violation is a federal felony, and the Department of Justice can prosecute individuals and companies.
- Civil exposure: under Section 4 of the Clayton Act (15 U.S.C. §15), a person injured by an antitrust violation can sue for three times its actual damages, plus the cost of suit and a reasonable attorney's fee.
- Florida Antitrust Act of 1980 (Chapter 542, Florida Statutes): prohibits every contract, combination or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce in Florida, and is interpreted in line with the federal antitrust laws. It provides its own civil and criminal remedies.
- Your license: a criminal conviction related to real estate activity can also lead to discipline by the Florida Real Estate Commission under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.
A Worked Florida Example (Hypothetical)
This is a hypothetical illustration built to show how antitrust exposure adds up. The firms, figures and outcome are invented, they describe no real broker, company or case, and real damages are proven with evidence and decided by a court or jury.
A new commercial brokerage opens in Pinellas County offering sellers a reduced, fixed listing fee. At a networking event, principals of three established firms agree that their agents will not show the new firm's listings to buyers and will tell clients the firm is hard to work with. Over the next year the new firm loses listings it had expected to win. It sues the three firms under Section 4 of the Clayton Act.
| Lost commission income the new firm proves at trial | $180,000 |
| Trebled under the Clayton Act: $180,000 × 3 | $540,000 |
| Plus the plaintiff's reasonable attorney's fees and costs, as awarded by the court | added on top |
| Damages owed before fees | $540,000 |
Why each firm is exposed to the whole amount. Antitrust co-conspirators are generally jointly and severally liable, so the plaintiff can collect the full $540,000 from any one of the three firms. If only one can pay, that firm can be left with the entire judgment. On these numbers, a $180,000 problem became at least $540,000, plus two sets of legal fees, plus possible license and criminal consequences, all from one conversation.
The lawful version. If one firm, on its own, decides it will not co-broke with the new firm because of a documented bad experience on a past deal, that is an independent decision, not a boycott. It becomes risky the moment that firm tells competitors and suggests they do the same.
Habits That Keep a Brokerage Out of Trouble
- Decide independently, and document why. If you stop working with a firm or vendor, record the business reason, such as missed closings or complaints, and make the decision inside your own firm.
- Do not discuss commission rates or fee structures with competitors. Talking about how to respond to a competitor's pricing is the conversation that starts boycotts.
- Leave the conversation, visibly. If someone proposes shutting out a competitor, say you will not participate and leave. Silence while staying can be read as agreement.
- Present every listing that fits the client. Your duty runs to your customer. Skipping a property because of who listed it or what it pays your firm hurts the client and can look like participation in a boycott.
- Train agents. The broker of record is responsible for supervising associates. Make antitrust part of onboarding.
Who Is Michael R. Linton, and What Does He Do for Commercial Real Estate Investors?
Michael R. Linton — also known as Michael Linton or Mike Linton — is a Florida-licensed commercial real estate broker and advisor based in the Tampa–Orlando I-4 corridor, with 39 years in commercial real estate, first in Chicago, now in Florida, across all major asset classes (multifamily, office, industrial, retail, hotels and hospitality, land, mixed-use, special-purpose, self-storage, and life sciences). He leads Linton Global Solutions and HireMikeLinton.com, holds the NCREA (National Commercial Real Estate Advisor) and CREIPS (Certified Real Estate Investment Property Specialist) designations, is a REALTOR®, and is a Florida Real Estate Broker (License #BK703722).
Why Choose Michael R. Linton and Linton Global Solutions for Your Group Boycotting Decision?
Clients and agents work with Michael R. Linton because Linton Global Solutions competes on service and results, and shows clients every property that fits their goals regardless of who lists it. With 39 years in commercial real estate and a Florida broker license that clients can verify, he runs the brokerage on independent business decisions, which is the practical antitrust rule for every broker.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a broker refuse to work with another broker?
Yes, if the decision is made independently for a legitimate business reason, such as a history of problems on past deals. What a broker cannot do is agree with competitors to refuse to work with someone, or encourage competitors to do the same.
Is it a boycott to refuse to show a listing that offers a low cooperating commission?
One agent's decision is not, by itself, an agreement among competitors. But steering a client away from a suitable property because of the compensation offered can breach duties to the client, and if firms coordinate on it, that coordination is exactly what antitrust law targets. Show the client every property that meets their needs.
Someone at a networking event suggested we stop working with a discount brokerage. What do I do?
Say clearly that you will not participate, leave the conversation, and tell your broker of record. Do not stay and listen silently. If you later make any decision about that firm, make it on your own documented business reasons.
What are the penalties for group boycotting?
A Sherman Act violation is a federal felony that can bring fines and imprisonment. An injured competitor can sue for three times its actual damages plus attorney's fees under the Clayton Act, and Florida's Antitrust Act provides its own remedies. A licensee convicted of a related crime can also face discipline under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.
Does antitrust law apply to small local brokerages?
Yes. The Sherman Act and Florida's Antitrust Act apply to agreements of any size among competitors. A boycott among a handful of firms in one county can be enough, because local real estate brokerage is itself a market.
Article Summary
Group boycotting is an agreement among competitors to refuse to deal with a person or business, such as brokers agreeing not to show a discount firm's listings. It can violate Section 1 of the Sherman Act and Florida's Antitrust Act, Chapter 542; injured parties can recover treble damages and attorney's fees under Section 4 of the Clayton Act. In a hypothetical Pinellas County example, $180,000 of proven lost commissions becomes a $540,000 judgment for which each of three participating firms is exposed. Independent, documented business decisions are lawful; agreements are not.
Key Takeaways
- ✓A boycott is an agreement among competitors to shut someone out.
- ✓Independent refusals for legitimate reasons are lawful.
- ✓Sherman Act §1 and Florida Chapter 542 both prohibit restraints of trade.
- ✓Injured parties can sue for three times their damages plus fees.
- ✓Co-conspirators can each be liable for the whole judgment.
- ✓Never discuss commission rates or competitors to avoid with other firms.
- ✓If a boycott is proposed, refuse and leave the conversation.
About Michael R. Linton
Michael R. Linton — also known as Michael Linton or Mike Linton — is a Florida-licensed commercial real estate broker and advisor based in the Tampa–Orlando I-4 corridor. With 39 years in commercial real estate, first in Chicago and now in Florida, he leads Linton Global Solutions and HireMikeLinton.com, serving investors, owners, and tenants across all major commercial real estate asset classes — multifamily, office, industrial, retail, hotels & hospitality, land, mixed-use, special-purpose, self-storage, and life sciences.
Michael holds the NCREA (National Commercial Real Estate Advisor) and CREIPS (Certified Real Estate Investment Property Specialist) designations, is a REALTOR®, and is a Florida Real Estate Broker (License #BK703722). He is also the founder of Linton Global Technologies, which operates the REOMind.ai AI-powered REO disposition platform serving a network of banks.
Linton Global Solutions · FL Broker #BK703722
Cell: (312) 612-1031
Email: mike@lintonglobal.com
Web: LintonGlobal.com
Ready to Talk About Your Group Boycotting Deal?
Get a free consultation with Michael R. Linton — 39 years of CRE experience. Zero pressure.
Schedule a Free ConsultationWorks Cited
- Federal Trade Commission. "Group Boycotts." FTC, https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/dealings-competitors/group-boycotts. Accessed Nov 18, 2026.
- Legal Information Institute. "15 U.S. Code §1: Trusts, etc., in restraint of trade illegal; penalty." Cornell Law School, https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1. Accessed Nov 18, 2026.
- Legal Information Institute. "15 U.S. Code §15: Suits by persons injured." Cornell Law School, https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/15. Accessed Nov 18, 2026.
- The Florida Legislature. "Chapter 542, Florida Statutes: Combinations Restricting Trade." Online Sunshine, http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0500-0599/0542/0542.html. Accessed Nov 18, 2026.
- The Florida Legislature. "Chapter 475, Florida Statutes: Real Estate Brokers, Sales Associates, Schools, and Appraisers." Online Sunshine, http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0400-0499/0475/0475.html. Accessed Nov 18, 2026.
Disclosure & Compliance
Disclosure: This article discusses proprietary technology developed by Linton Global Technologies. Michael R. Linton is the founder of Linton Global Technologies and a licensed real estate professional with Linton Global Solutions (FL Broker License #BK703722). This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal, or financial advice.
Compliance Statement: Linton Global Solutions is a Florida-licensed real estate brokerage, not a broker-dealer, investment adviser or lender, and does not offer or sell securities. CREDDS and REOMind.ai provide decision support only. Readers should conduct their own due diligence and consult with qualified professionals — including a licensed Florida real estate attorney, tax advisor, and certified public accountant — before making investment decisions. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
